A Nonparametric Analysis of Black-White Differences in Intergenerational Income Mobility in the United States (REVISED March 2011)

This paper concerns the problem of inferring the effects of covariates on intergenerational income mobility, i.e. on the relationship between the incomes of parents and future earnings of their children. The authors focus on two different measures of mobility--1) traditional transition probability of movement across income quantiles over generations, and 2) a new direct measure of upward mobility, viz. the probability that an adult child's relative position exceeds that of the parents. The authors estimate the effect of possibly continuously distributed covariates from data using nonparametric regression and average derivatives and derive the distribution theory for these measures. The analytical novelty in the derivation is that the dependent variables involve nonsmooth functions of estimated components- marginal quantiles for transition probabilities and relative ranks for upward mobility- thus necessitating nontrivial modifications of standard nonparametric regression theory. They use these methods on U.S. data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth to study black-white differences in intergenerational mobility, a topic which has received scant attention in the literature. They document that whites experience greater intergenerational mobility than blacks. Estimates of conditional mobility using nonparametric regression reveal that most of the interracial mobility gap can be accounted for by differences in cognitive skills during adolescence. The methods developed here have wider applicability to estimation of nonparametric regression and average derivatives where the dependent variable either involves a preliminary finite-dimensional estimate in a nonsmooth way or is a nonsmooth functional of ranks of one or more random variables.